Posted Sunday, June 29, 2003

Quick navigation

Alphabetical index (text)  

London, Sunday, June 29, 2003

"Hannibal the cannibal' to star as Irving the Holocaust denier

By Catherine Milner and Chris Hastings

THE trial of David Irving, the British historian branded a Holocaust denier by a High Court judge, is to be turned into a £10 million drama, expected to star Sir Anthony Hopkins.

David Irving comments:

The Telegraph newspaper group was once famously owned by the Berry family.
It was purchased by the Hollinger Group and came thereby under the control of the fiercely pro-Zionist Conrad Black and his wife Barbara Amiel [but just look what they once made her write about me!].
   Hence their Freudian lapse in the opening line, "The trial of David Irving..."
   I have sent this corrective letter to the newspaper . . .

So Sir Anthony Hopkins is to portray me in the coming HBO film of my libel action. I thought it was already old history. He's one of our finest actors, and I have no fears on that score -- but I couldn't help noticing that while your online edition provided helpful links to every website hostile to me, including the Holocaust Educational Trust, the "charity" which first put secret pressure on Macmillan Ltd to destroy all my books in 1991 -- you did not provide a link to my own huge award-winning website, which now ranks in the top 20,000 of the World Wide Web. Chris Hastings can't claim ignorance of it -- he told me it was from here that he picked up the story in the first place.

Hopkins, Spielberg

Anthony Hopkins with friends

Related file:

Macmillan Ltd capitulates and secretly destroys all Mr Irving's books in July 1992

Ridley Scott, the director of Gladiator and Alien, is to produce the film, based on the libel trial three years ago in which Irving was called an "anti-Semite and racist" who "distorted historical data to suit his own political agenda".

The declaration effectively ended Irving's career, during which he had argued that Hitler did not plan a "Final Solution" for Jews. His court defeat was hailed by campaigners against Holocaust denial.

The film is being scripted by Ronald Harwood, who won an Oscar last year for the screenplay of the Holocaust drama The Pianist. Scott is keen for the role of Irving to be played by Hopkins, who won fame as the cannibalistic serial killer Hannibal Lecter in The Silence of the Lambs.

One senior executive involved in the project said: "The film will be the definitive story of the trial and its role in the Holocaust story. As far as both Scott and Harwood are concerned, Hopkins has the first say on the role. The part is his for the asking."

The drama is being produced by HBO, the American production company behind The Gathering Storm, the recent award-winning drama about Churchill starring Albert Finney, on which Scott was the executive producer. The Irving libel trial came about after the American historian Deborah Lipstadt condemned him in her 1994 book Denying the Holocaust: The Growing Assault on Truth and Memory. Irving sued, saying the description of him as a man prepared to bend historical evidence "until it conforms with his ideological leanings and political agenda" was damaging to his career.

Irving - a heroic figure to some far-Right groups - represented himself during the trial, in which he argued that the number of Jews killed by the Nazis had been exaggerated and that there had been no programme of "systematic extermination".

However, Mr Justice Gray ruled that Irving was an anti-Semitic racist whose claims were demonstrably untrue, and ordered him to meet the £2.5 million costs of the case. An appeal by Irving was rejected and he has since been declared bankrupt.

Professor Lipstadt has discussed the script with Mr Harwood and is very enthusiastic about the film project.

"I am very pleased that Ronald is involved and that the film is being done by the team behind The Gathering Storm," she said. "There is always a danger with things like this that they can end up generating publicity for people who don't deserve publicity. I don't think that will happen here: these are serious people who will bring a professional and committed approach to the story."

Irving, 63, told The Telegraph he had not been approached by anyone connected with the project, but added that he would be happy to help whoever was going to portray him.

David Irving

"I'm relatively relaxed about the whole thing," he said. "If it is an accurate portrayal, they'll have to reflect some of my arguments and show that I was fighting on my own against a massive team of lawyers."

He thought the American public found Holocaust dramas "a big turn-off", but added: "I think a story like this will work best as a courtroom drama. I just hope they give me a fair crack of the whip."


© Copyright of Telegraph Group Limited 2003.

External links



  Index to items on the Ridley Scott film of the Lipstadt trial


The above news item is reproduced without editing other than typographical
 Register your name and address to go on the Mailing List to receive

David Irving's ACTION REPORT

© Focal Point 2003 F Irving write to David Irving