Letters to David Irving on this Website

Unless correspondents ask us not to, this Website will post selected letters that it receives and invite open debate.


Samuel Crowell is a pseudonym. The author is an academic.

"Samuel Crowell" writes from the United States, Monday, October 19, 1998:

Thank you very much for the documents that you have been posting for the "historical community" and which are quite useful. I would make two brief comments about two of the documents:

(a) The document describing the single "gas oven" at Auschwitz on the basis of the 1944 interrogation demonstrates again a certain confusion in the mind of the Allies of what it is they are looking at. Most cremation ovens are "gas ovens" to the extent that they use heat generated by gaseous combustion of some kind: the "gas oven" described, "with chimney attached", can be no more than this. In the same way, cremation ovens per se are not evidence of criminality nor even planned mass murder (as we both know Nazi Germany were advocates of cremation for everybody: shortage of burial space, and, with an eye to India, perhaps a theoretical "Aryan" justification.)

(b) The document quoting 30 eyewitnesses has them assembling at the Sauna where they spend the whole day being showered, and having their clothing deloused, every four weeks. As it happens the method of delousing employed at the Central Sauna involved steam and hot air, but of course other methods including microwaves, and gases of various kinds (Zyklon B, T-Gas, and "Original") were also used for this purpose.

However, if these prisoners were kept at the Sauna all day so that they and their clothing would be deloused, it is likely that their barracks was also being disinfested of disease-bearing insects, and the substance that was used for this purpose was usually Zyklon B. (See Diary of Dr. Joseph Kremer, September 1, 1942). It follows that Auschwitz Birkenau would have been in great need of Zyklon during the Spring and Summer of 1944, for purely hygienic purposes, and your document laterally supports this idea. Incidentally, the document also supports the idea that rumors of gassing were widespread at the camp.

"Samuel Crowell"

 David Irving notes:

 I am not an expert on any of this. How good was his 1944 map? Does it compare with the air photos. It was Auschwitz I (Stammlager, right?). You will find that I am posting documents regardless of whether they help or hinder the revisionists. My main criterion is that they are genuine documents. Everything helps history.

"Samuel Crowell" responds:-

The map looks generally like the Stammlager but with the exactitude of someone cribbing an aerial photograph as the basis for a drawing, although the number of barracks is a bit scanty: remember the map is from 1941, the interrogation from 1944, and there was a lot of building going on in between.

You are right, "everything helps history", and that should be your sole criterion. . . . Furthermore, the documentation you provide anent mass shootings and other forms of maltreatment will help convert other revisionists away from wholesale rejectionism of Jewish claims of mass murder.

Letters Index

To Order Books | Auschwitz Index | Irving Index | Irving Page | Irving Book-List | Action Report | Other FP Authors
Buchladen | Auschwitz | Irving-Verzeichnis | -Hauptseite | -Bücher | Action Report | Weitere FP-Autoren
©Focal Point 1998 e-mail: write to David Irving