Posted Monday, November 3, 2003

[] Index to the Traditional Enemies of Free Speech
[] Alphabetical index (text)

Quick navigation

BBC News


General GuenzelGerman general axed in Jewish row

THE head of Germany's special forces has been sacked for allegedly backing an MP who is accused of anti-Semitism.

Defence Minister Peter Struck fired Brigadier General Reinhard Günzel for apparently praising MP Martin Hohmann.

Mr Hohmann has caused a national row with comments comparing the actions of Jews in the 1917 Russian revolution with those of the Nazis.

General Günzel is said to have written to Mr Hohmann, praising his "courage".

Mr Struck insisted that General Guenzel's views were not widespread in the armed forces.

"This is about a lone, confused general who agreed with an even more confused statement made by a conservative member of parliament," he said.


Mr Hohmann first sparked a furore when he suggested it might be possible to consider Jews as a "Tätervolk", or race of perpetrators, as Germans are seen, because of Jewish actions during the Bolshevik revolution.

In an interview for ZDF's Frontal 21 programme this weekend Mr Hohmann, an MP for the opposition right-wing Christian Democrats (CDU), read out the letter of support from General Günzel.

"It was an excellent speech, of a courage truth and clarity which one seldom hears or reads in our country," Mr Hohmann quoted the letter as saying.

"Even though all those who support this view or who articulate it loud and clear are categorised by public opinion as right-wing extremists, you can be sure that you are doubtless speaking for the majority of our nation," he also quoted the general as writing.

The KSK special forces, which General Günzel headed, are the elite branch of the German military and have recently seen action in Afghanistan.


German prosecutors have launched an investigation into Mr Hohmann's speech after a criminal complaint against him was filed.

He has apologised for his comments, saying that neither Germans nor Jews were "Tätervolk".

The CDU has thrown him off two parliamentary commissions - though critics say that this is not punishment enough.



... on Hohmann's speech

Forced to apologise: Nicht sein kann, was nicht sein darf | faces legal probe

Outrage in Berlin Conservative German politician claims Jews are "a Race of Perpetrators" | full text of his speech

Korherr report, on percentage of Jews in Russian Communist Party, 1926/27

David Irving Uprising. The 1956 Uprising in Hungary (free download)

Michael Hoffmann on the role of Jews in the Bolshevik and subsequent atrocities

E-H. Schwacke of South Africa adds facts on the Jewish assassins of the Tsar's family

Outrage in Israel Poland demands extradition of Solomon Morel for genocide at Polish prison camp

The good, the bad, the downright ugly Lea Rosh (right) objects to Degussa firm working on her $27m Holocaust memorial in Berlin

The above news item is reproduced without editing other than typographical

 Register your name and address to go on the Mailing List to receive

David Irving's ACTION REPORT

© Focal Point 2003 F Irving write to David Irving