The International Campaign for Real History

Posted Monday, January 10, 2005

[] Index to the Traditional Enemies of Free Speech
[] Alphabetical index (text)
AR-Online

Quick navigation

January 17, 2005

Unanswered Questions [Website: among others, the American use of the Israeli flag as torture]

Alberto Gonzales will likely be confirmed. But that won't stop the widening scandal over Gitmo [Guantánamo] detainees

By Michael Isikoff
Newsweek

Jan. 17 issue - Ibraham Al Qosi's stories seemed fairly outlandish when they first surfaced last fall. In a lawsuit, Al Qosi, a Sudanese accountant apprehended after 9/11 on suspicions of ties to Al Qaeda, charged that he and other detainees at Guantánamo Bay had been subjected to bizarre forms of humiliation and abuse by U.S. military inquisitors.

Al Qosi claimed they were strapped to the floor in an interrogations center known as the Hell Room, wrapped in Israeli flags, taunted by female interrogators who rubbed their bodies against them in sexually suggestive ways, and left alone in refrigerated cells for hours with deafening music blaring in their ears. Back then, Pentagon officials dismissed Al Qosi's allegations as the fictional rantings of a hard-core terrorist.

positive discriminationBut in recent weeks a stack of declassified government documents has given new credence to many of the claims of abuse at Guantanamo. The documents are also raising fresh questions about the Bush administration's handling of detainees at a time when a prime architect of that policy, White House counsel Alberto Gonzales, right, is facing a Senate confirmation vote as the president's nominee to be attorney general.

Many of the documents come from an unexpected source: the FBI. As part of a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit brought by the American Civil Liberties Union, the bureau has released internal e-mails and correspondence recording what their own agents witnessed at Gitmo. Coupled with accounts from other agencies such as the Defense Intelligence AgencyÐalso released as part of the FOIA lawsuitÐthe FBI reports amount to a powerful case that many of the scenes alleged by Al Qosi and other Gitmo detainees may actually have happened. (Al Qosi is still in Gitmo, facing charges before a military tribunal.) And the reports suggest that the interrogation scandal is not going away any time soon, even if Gonzales is confirmed, as expected.

Many of the FBI accounts came from conscience-stricken agents troubled by what they had witnessed.

  • One agent reported seeing a detainee sitting on the floor of an interrogation cell with an Israeli flag draped around him while he was bombarded by loud music and a strobe lightÐalmost exactly what Al Qosi had alleged.
  • Another reported seeing detainees chained hand and foot in fetal positions, in barren cells with no chair, food or water.
  • In one account that seemed to parallel the sickening scenes from Abu Ghraib Prison in Iraq, an FBI agent reported the way in which a female U.S. Army sergeant sexually humiliated a shackled male prisoner during Ramadan and even "grabbed his genitals."

Pentagon officials acknowledge that, frustrated by detainees' refusal to talk, Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld had approved "aggressive" interrogation techniques to be used at Gitmo. But last week, stunned by the new disclosures, Gen. Bantz Craddock, chief of the U.S. Southern Command -- which runs Gitmo -- ordered a full-scale inquiry into the FBI agents' allegations, which appear to go far beyond anything authorized. Craddock wants to know why allegations from seemingly credible government agents had not come to the U.S. military's attention sooner.

After hearing of the FBI memos, NEWSWEEK has learned, Sens. Dianne Feinstein and Patrick Leahy fired off angry letters to FBI Director Robert Mueller demanding to know why he failed to disclose his own agents' complaints when they questioned him about Gitmo in a hearing last May.

Feinstein last week called Mueller's evasive answers at the time "gobbledygook." When her comment was reported on NEWSWEEK's Web site, Mueller called Feinstein to express regret that he hadn't kept her better informed. As the inquiries continue, he may not be the only U.S. government official who has further explaining to do.

© 2005 Newsweek, Inc.
 

The Face of war, mass murder and genocide - Civilian casualties - families murdered in their own homes - during the US assault on Fallujah (Warning: graphic images)
Future historians will deem the Bush regime's enthusiasm for torture the most striking aspect of its cuurrent wars
Ban on torture overruled in Pentagon
Bush Claimed Right to Waive Torture Laws
Lawyer for one guard claims picture shows his client taking orders from others - will generals take the stand?
Harvard Law Professor Alan Dershowitz says U.S. Needs Improved Torture Tactics
Okay for some "Bundeswehrprofessor [Michael Wolffsohn, jüdisch, Israeli-Bürger] räsoniert über Vorzüge der Folter": German professor Michael Wolffsohn calls for use of torture | Summoned before his minister
Expanding the Taguba report: Israel's role in training US army in torture techniques
Danish government accuses British troops Danish medics witnessed Iraqi prisoner die after interrogation
Reuters agency released shocking details of US torture of three of its journalists
Israel's involvement in Iraq: has torture experts at Abu Ghraib Jail
Israeli medical association: OK to break fingers of Palestinian prisoners during interrogation
Amnesty International reports, Israel Supreme Court to Rule on Torture and Holding of Lebanese Hostages as Pawns
Human rights lawyers argue that Israel's torture of Palestinians is illegal (but sometimes necessary)
Lipstadt's Witness Bernie Farber is Revealed as Torture Apologist
Carmi GillonIsraeli torture of Palestinian prisoners seized in the notorious Khiam prison in southern Lebanon
Sydney Morning Herald reports: US creating torture centers in non-US locations "It allows us to get information from terrorists in a way we can't do on US soil."
Robert Fisk reports: Inside an Israeli torturers' den, manacles lie abandoned
Danish opposition to the appointment of Israeli torture chief, Ambassador Carmi Gillon (right)
Torture of children by USA's closest allies
 

The above item is reproduced without editing other than typographical
© Focal Point 2005 F Irving write to David Irving