| [images and
captions added by this website]  Wellington, New Zealand, Wednesday, October 19,
2005
Genocide a
growth area of study by Colin
Patterson THE Holocaust has always held a
fascination for Simone Gigliotti. While
growing up in Australia, she heard stories from her
grandparents who fled Mussolini's fascist
dictatorship in Italy in the early
1920s. Studying history at Melbourne University, her
interest in humanitarian issues encouraged her to
delve into what happened during the Holocaust and
why. Now a history lecturer at Victoria University,
Dr Gigliotti researches and teaches about
Hitler's Final Solution and its
consequences.  David
Irving comments: THANKS for sending me
that; it is of course absurd to say I deny
the Holocaust, in the normal and commonly
understood sense of the words, as anybody
who has read my books knows. I just refuse to
buy the whole Package, let alone swallow
it the way that many journalists and some
judges are willing to do, for need of a
cushier existence. INCIDENTALLY now that New Zealand has
survived the trauma of a general election,
I shall now be making my formal
application for special permission to
enter the country to deliver my
much delayed talk to the National Press
Club. A new legal battle may well
loom.  | In a world where those such as British historian
David Irving deny the
Holocaust ever happened or claim there was
never a plan to exterminate Jews Dr Gigliotti said
her research had left her in no doubt."I believe it happened.
I believe the Nazis had an intentional strategy
to persecute and marginalise Jews by any means
possible."
[Website
comment: Uh, that's not quite the same thing as
a Holocaust].
She supports the Government's 2004 decision to
deny Irving a visa to speak at the National Press
Club. "I think David Irving has no place in Holocaust
history. He is part of a marginal group. The frequent quoted figure of six million
Holocaust deaths was no exaggeration, said Dr
Gigliotti. Nazi gas chambers claimed three million people,
while two million died in massacres that followed
the German invasion of the Soviet Union in 1941.
The remaining million died in other forms of
detention or as a result of the state's
discriminatory practices. Dr Gigliotti's most recent research focuses on
the psychological effects on Jews of the methods
used to transport them to concentration camps
usually in railway wagons
normally used for cattle. [Website
comment: Untrue -- click to see our image of
Stuttgart's deported Jews arriving at Riga,
November 1941. So much for the standard of
Holocaust teachers in New Zealand -- and perhaps
the real reason why they did not want Mr Irving to
speak there. . .]
She believes the transportation process has been
overlooked by con temporary historians, who have
tend ed to focus on what happened after internees
arrived at their destinations. "I want to find out what it was like to be
confined in carriages for long periods. There was
definitely a policy of causing pain." The trains were essential. It would have been
impossible to move so many people by road,
especially in the height of war. Thousands of Jews who filled
the cattle trains
never made it, as harsh conditions including a lack
of water and food took their toll, especially among
the elderly and the young. Stories of conditions on trains did get around.
Yet one of the big mysteries was that many people
got on board willingly. "They had been living in terrible conditions
especially a lack of food. They thought that by
getting on the train, conditions would get
better." But they did not. Many of those who arrived at the camps were
immediately selected for death. Most were women,
children or the elderly because they were
considered less valuable sources of labour. Her sources are published and unpublished
testimonies and memoirs of survivors. "Those
memoirs are sometimes of exceptional quality, even
though survivors often don't have a lot of writing
ability." She also teaches and researches the wider field
of genocide, extending from the Holocaust to modern
variants, such as Rwanda civil war and ethnic
cleansing in the Balkans. While the horrors of genocide are well known,
its causes are less clear. "Genocide is preventable. But more scholarship
and research is necessary to help identify its
causes." Many perpetrators are provocateurs who are not
necessarily those who pull the trigger. But race
and racism are essential ingredients, she said. And
with race-based conflicts festering throughout the
world, Dr Gigliotti is not confident that genocide
can be consigned to the dustbin of history. "Unfortunately, genocide is a growth area of
study."  on this website
Our
Auschwitz dossier
|