The International Campaign for Real History
Check out the new David Irving bookstore at

Posted Friday, August 8, 2008

[] Index to the Traditional Enemies of Free Speech
[] Alphabetical index (text)


Quick navigation

[All images added by this website]

Jewish Telegraph Agency, August 6, 2008

Happier Times: When Solzhenitsyn could not put a foot wrong. Then he did, and he wandered into the ranks of The Undead.

Sharansky lauds Solzhenitsyn's influence on Soviet Jewry movement

By Ben Harris

NEW YORK (JTA) -- Amid the haystack of laudatory prose evoked this week by the death of one of the titans of Russian literature was this far less flattering needle: Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn was dogged, particularly in his later years, by charges he harbored deep anti-Semitic prejudice.

[Nathan] Sharansky, who along with Solzhenitsyn is among the most famous inmates and chroniclers of the Soviet labor camp system, says those charges should be understood in context.

"I don't think that he has any special prejudice," Sharansky told JTA. "He had a big interest in defending the Russian nationalism, the Russian pride. Also he wanted to unmask the evils of the empire. While studying it, he discovered -- it was very easy to discover -- that among the architects of this gulag system, meaning this system of imprisonment, were many, many Jews.
click for origin

David Irving comments:

I HAVE always had a warm spot for Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, and not only because he wrote to me, out of the blue from his exile in Vermont, a fine handwritten letter praising my earliest book The Destruction of Dresden, USA, many years ago.
   He was a brave man, and it is interesting to see that despite his immense prestige as a Nobel Prize winner, the traditional enemies of the truth have had no hesitation in targeting him for his revelations about their prominent role in the Soviet terror system.
   It is almost as though they still hanker after those good ole times.
   His condemnation of the Soviet terror system and the Jewish role therein was nothing new of course: as early as 1920 Winston Churchill wrote an article in a London illustrated magazine, before he was bought off by that big cheque from Sir Robert Waley-Cohen in July 1936, excoriating them for this particularly ugly facet of the their past.
   But that was years before the Holocaust and its associated media industry brought down a fire-safety curtain blotting out all such critical references to their more controversial achievements.
   Solzhenitsyn's courage deserves even greater posthumous recognition in consequence.

Jewish exile from Russia Nathan Sharansky criticised the great Nobel Prize winner for "anti semitism". Quoi de neuf.


"So for him these Jews became the symbol of the worst" types of Jews, those Jews who lost their own identity and tried to take away the identity of others, said Sharansky, whose own struggle became a symbol of the Soviet Jewry movement before he immigrated in 1986 to Israel, where he has served in the national government.

Solzhenitsyn first came to prominence in 1963 with the publication of "A Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich," a short novel describing the harsh conditions of a Soviet labor camp. He went on to publish "The Gulag Archipelago," his best-selling work, and is credited with some of the worst indictments of Soviet depredation to appear in print. He won the Nobel Prize for literature in 1970.

For nearly two decades, Solzhenitsyn lived in exile in the United States, taking up residence on a secluded farm in Cavendish, Vermont. He returned to Russia after the fall of communism, and in his later years embraced President Vladimir Putin, whom he saw as a figure capable of restoring Russian greatness.

Solzhenitsyn died Sunday in Moscow at 89.

Sharansky, then known as Anatoly Sharansky, met Solzhenitsyn briefly in the early 1970s, though he describes himself as more firmly in the camp of another dissident [Jewish] writer, Andrei Sakharov.

Nevertheless, Sharansky recalls traveling hundreds of miles from Moscow to read underground copies of Solzhenitsyn's work. And he credits the writer with helping the Soviet Jewry effort by laying bare the brutality of the Soviet regime.

It became much easier for the Soviet Jewry movement "to mobilize the support of the world for us" because "the world already knew, thanks to Solzhenitsyn, that it was an evil empire, and it was much easier for us to make our case," Sharansky said.

"So whether he agreed or disagreed -- and there were some tactical disagreements between us and him -- his contribution was enormous. In fact he helped us to build our struggle."

In his later years Solzhenitsyn wrote a two-volume history of Russians and Jews titled "Two Hundred Years Together," in which he described the prominence of Jews in the Bolshevik revolution. Others have found traces of his animus toward Jews in the portrayal of Jewish characters in his novels.

But as The Independent in England reported, the issue was more complex given that his second wife was Jewish and their three sons from that marriage were raised as Jews.

For Sharansky, Solzhenitsyn's view on Jews was peripheral to his legacy.

"Definitely he's not objective," Sharansky said. "Definitely he tries to justify things which one shouldn't try to justify. But I have to say, having said all this, with all these prejudices, they played in fact no role in his influence on the world. They were really so marginal.

"Whether he had some prejudices against Jews or not -- and he had some -- it wasn't really the meaning of his influence on the people of the world."

Hear David Irving speak in England and the United States this year. Get his books at special prices, too.

Apply by clicking on this link.

David Irving, a Radical's Diary: He speaks in Manhattan and Washington, and a journalist called Blumenthal interviews him on film: YouTube version | Blumenthal writes on Huffington Post

The above item is reproduced without editing other than typographical

 Register your name and address to go on the Mailing List to receive

David Irving's ACTION REPORT

or to hear when and where he will next speak near you

© Focal Point 2008 Irving write to David Irving